When a Marine Gunnery Sergeant faced a life-altering court-martial at Quantico, the prosecution alleged dereliction of duty leading to death arising from an incident during an Africa deployment. The charge carried severe criminal exposure and the very real prospect of a destroyed career, lost retirement, and permanent stigma. The stakes were as high as they come in military justice.

Cave & Freeburg, LLP stepped in. What followed was a model of meticulous investigation, disciplined pretrial litigation, and aggressive courtroom advocacy—culminating in a full acquittal and the restoration of a Marine’s reputation.

Background: The Government’s Theory

1. Charges and Sentence

Charge and Specification

• Appellant, Private First Class Avery L. Rosario, U.S. Marine Corps, pleaded guilty to:

If you are on active duty and married to an undocumented “alien,” you have two concerns (1) how to get your spouse “legal,” and (2) avoiding disciplinary action.

Your Legal Jeopardy

Service members often ask whether marrying or living with an undocumented spouse exposes them to court-martial. The short answer is yes, in limited and fact-specific circumstances—but the risk most often arises from paperwork and benefits errors, not from marriage itself.

1. Charges and Sentence

Charges/Specifications:

The appellant, Chief Hospital Corpsman (E-7) Marvin B. Guzman, U.S. Navy, was tried by general court-martial at Naval Base San Diego, California, and convicted by members with enlisted representation of:

United States v. Marschalek, No. ACM S32776 (A.F. Ct. Crim. App. Jan. 16, 2026).

1. Charges and Sentence

Special Court-Martial, RAF Lakenheath, United Kingdom.

Why Judicial Recusal Protects You in a court-martial

A Cave & Freeburg, Military Lawyers, Client Explainer

When you face investigation, adverse administrative action, or court-martial, one principle stands above all others: your case must be heard by a fair and impartial judge. The military justice system—like every American court—recognizes that justice collapses when a judge appears biased or influenced. Recusal, the process by which a judge steps aside, protects your right to a neutral decision-maker.

Cave & Freeburg, Military Defense Counsel

It is Holiday-Season

At Cave & Freeburg, we represent service members worldwide. One of the most common questions we receive each beginning after Thanksgiving is  how will the holidays affect my case.