Toobin on toolong

CNN Justice reports:

Toobin: Cabinet members may end up negotiating which legal system will try Army Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan, the suspect in last week’s mass shooting at Fort Hood in Texas, CNN senior legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin said Tuesday.

CNN: Would the charges be the same in either case?

Toobin: The wording would be different but there would be no practical difference. Most importantly, he would be eligible for the death penalty in either jurisdiction. I don’t believe there has been a military execution in a very long time. I know there are some people on death row in military court. There is no parole in federal court, but there is time off for good behavior. You can get up to 15 percent off for good behavior.

1.  If prosecuted at court-martial the primary charges will include a violation of Article 118, UCMJ, and Article 119a, UCMJ (causing death of unborn child).  This is Article 118, UCMJ.

image

Article 119a is fairly new: image

2.  The last military execution was of Private Bennett in 1961 for rape and murder.

3.  (Courtesy of DHSullivan: “Since the current military death penalty system went into effect in 1984, 15 known military death sentences have been adjudged.  In two of those cases, the CA commuted the death sentence to confinement for life.  Of the remaining 13 cases, three remain on appeal at the CCA level.  That leaves 10 cases that have completed direct appellate review.  Of those, the death sentence was affirmed in two cases and reversed in eight.  In those eight cases, the death sentence was reversed in three cases due in whole or in part to IAC (Curtis, Murphy, Kreutzer, which also involved an erroneous deprivation of resources to the defense counsel).  In two of those three cases (Curtis and Kreutzer) the original death sentence was replaced by a life sentence.  Resentencing hasn’t yet occurred in the third case, Murphy.”